01:56:50 · John Coogan, Sean Frank, Jordi Hays, Bernt Øivind Børnich, Jeffrey Morgan, Eric Seufert
[01:56:50] S1: two It was good [01:56:50] S6: for you. Oh, it was awesome. [01:56:51] S1: Yeah. Interesting. [01:56:52] S6: I think they're getting So way [01:56:53] S0: so Yeah. Do you think that it was actually bad bad for some people, or they were just going through a slump in their business overall? They had, like, business problems that they wanted to blame on [01:57:04] S5: the ad changes. [01:57:06] S6: Well, dude, yeah. I mean, what's new, right? It's like, everyone so if your business is going bad, it's everyone else's fault. Yeah. But really, like, you know, they do, like, the meta performance summit every May. [01:57:15] S3: Mhmm. [01:57:15] S6: And they've just rolled out so many great changes to the ad algorithm that, like, I think you're getting better impressions with better people. [01:57:22] S2: Yeah. [01:57:22] S6: And I the more compute and AI they throw out, I think it's just gonna get better and better. And, like, we're gonna do it like a future where, like, the perfect impression at the perfect time with the perfect ad that's, like, customized to the person with AI, that's coming. [01:57:35] S1: Yeah. [01:57:35] S6: And click through rates will go up, conversion rates will go up, and CPMs will go up with it. But I think there'll be, like, a moment of arbitrage there.
01:57:35 · Sean Frank, John Coogan, Jordi Hays
[01:57:35] S6: And click through rates will go up, conversion rates will go up, and CPMs will go up with it. But I think there'll be, like, a moment of arbitrage there. [01:57:42] S1: Do do you think do you think Zuck is doing enough to actually message that to customers like you? Because Ben Thompson put out this piece on Monday, sort of an earnings call transcript that he wrote in the voice of Mark Zuckerberg, and his pitch was to investors, telling the investors, hey. Look. We are investing a lot in AI, but it's all in service of the ads business, which is great, which we do take seriously. We have taken some side quests, done some metaverse, some VR stuff. But this investment that we're making right now, you shouldn't beat us up in the public markets because it's going to come back huge. We're growing really fast on the ad side. 33% is massive at that scale, and it's gonna continue to double down. But I'm wondering if if advertisers are are receiving that signal from Meta that it is going to get better. It is some place that they should be spending more time and more dollars. [01:58:34] S6: Yeah. We're a captive audience, so I don't think he has to message to us. [01:58:37] S1: He doesn't. He [01:58:37] S6: he can talk [01:58:38] S0: to you more. Yeah.
01:58:38 · Jordi Hays, Sean Frank, Bernt Øivind Børnich, John Coogan
[01:58:38] S0: to you more. Yeah. [01:58:38] S6: Yeah. Like, the best thing he could do is get people to spend more time on their app. Yeah. Right? And then better understand who those people are and what they're in market for. Mhmm. And if he delivers those things, the ad dollars will come. Mhmm. Because besides that, like, where else we're gonna spend money? [01:58:49] S5: Yeah. [01:58:49] S6: Like, TikTok shop's actually doing great, but it's still a really small business. Right? Like, the GMV this year in America might be 20,000,000,000. [01:58:56] S1: Really? [01:58:56] S6: And Amazon does that, like, every four days or something. So it's like, it's still a very, very small business. [01:59:01] S1: Why is TikTok so small? Is it is it a separate panel or something? I feel like TikTok still has so many so many impressions, so many videos that are being served. Do you do you have an idea of why that business is [01:59:13] S0: falling out? I think it's it's not necessarily I think it's primarily that content platforms have been a place you discover products, but not where you transact. Like Meta has done a lot of had a lot of efforts in shopping in app. They never you would have thought that they would have clicked harder. Yeah. Right? It's like you have this captive audience that uses your product for an hour a day to discover things to buy, and they're not buying that many products in the app. [01:59:40] S1: Yeah.
01:59:40 · John Coogan, Sean Frank, Jordi Hays
[01:59:40] S1: Yeah. [01:59:40] S6: Yeah. And TikTok shop is delivering way more value than 20,000,000,000 in GMV. Like, a a brand is, like, Comfort Hoodies. I'm sure you guys have seen them. They're doing 1,000,000,000 a year right now. They're four years [01:59:51] S0: old. Last time time you told me about them, I think it was, like, 400 or something [01:59:55] S6: like they've more than doubled. Yeah. It's crazy. [01:59:57] S1: Yeah. Yeah. [01:59:57] S6: Yeah. And all it is is, like, TikTok shop affiliates. So people posting thousands of videos a day. They take those the best videos of it. Yep. They put it into TikTok shop GMV max. Yeah. They run that. And their TikTok shop business might do might do a 100,000,000 a year, but the spillover is crazy. Everyone goes to Amazon. Everyone goes to your website. [02:00:14] S1: Oh, got it. [02:00:15] S6: So, like Yeah. Yeah. They've just done a horrible job actually capturing the value they're generating. [02:00:19] S1: Interesting. But they're getting a lot of impressions. They're driving a of purchases. What's the sweet spot for price point on TikTok shop? That hoodie company, is that a $70 hoodie? [02:00:28] S6: It's cheaper. Right? Like, it's a successful product in TikTok shop is female focused Mhmm. Impulse buy. So like, you know, $20, $30, $40, something like that. And then you have people to make outrageous claims. Right? And so Yeah. Yeah. Comfort hoodies is like it's a hoodie that cures anxiety. Yeah. So, like, that's pretty good. [02:00:45] S1: Like, it's [02:00:46] S6: a pretty good value prop.
02:00:46 · Sean Frank, John Coogan
[02:00:46] S6: a pretty good value prop. [02:00:47] S1: Claim the FDA might wake up to that one at [02:00:49] S6: some point. All the affiliates are making it, so who cares? Yeah. [02:00:53] S1: Somebody should care, but we'll see. Yeah. A little bit of a gray area. Interesting. Are there any I I I wanna know about when you're using AI personally in house or someone on your team is using AI, like the models or the products, like ChatGPT, Claude, etcetera, versus you feel like you're getting AI for free because you're using Mailchimp and Mailchimp integrated AI, or you're on Shopify and Shopify gave you an AI feature for free. [02:01:25] S6: Yeah. You know, I I don't wanna talk too bad about any sponsors. I don't know if Notion sponsors you guys. They don't. Okay. Great. You would actually hope that more of these companies would be rolling out AI faster and better and more useful. Because like, you know, we're using it internally a ton directly with the models. And like inventory planning and buying is a solved problem. [02:01:44] S1: Okay. [02:01:44] S6: That was like the biggest problem that has plagued [02:01:46] S1: Yeah. Like Like demand forecasting. [02:01:48] S6: Yeah. Like all of that is like [02:01:49] S1: And then a proposal to a supplier or or in your case, like the actual factory to to understand how many you're gonna sell by month, when they need to be delivered, what would the shipping timelines, all of that's just a bunch of Excel work normally. [02:02:03] S6: Yeah. And it was huge teams. [02:02:04] S1: And if
02:02:04 · John Coogan, Sean Frank, Jordi Hays, Thibault Sottiaux
[02:02:04] S1: And if [02:02:04] S6: you got it wrong, it bankrupted your company. Yep. Right? Like, you had bad inventory or you get, like, shorts in December. Right? Like Yeah. Yeah. It ruined a bunch of businesses. Mhmm. AI has totally solved that. Really? Working directly with coexes of the world, right, and just putting in all of your your business information. [02:02:18] S1: Such a huge unlock for the global economy. It's, like, crazy to think of. [02:02:22] S0: We gotta tell we gotta tell consumers that don't like AI. Your favorite brands are doing perfect forecasting. [02:02:30] S1: And that means that [02:02:31] S0: you are gonna get the perfect article of clothing right before your trip to Hawaii even though you waited until three days before to order it. [02:02:39] S6: Always have the right sizes in stock. That is coming because of Kodak. That's crazy. [02:02:43] S0: This is this is this is, like, part of what, the Souffinator was talking about. Right? Like, the the one of the Eric Suvert moped up memo. He he was just talking about, like, actually, if you have, like, better advertising because of AI, it will create a like like, it will drive economic growth purely because you have more and more of these, niche businesses that might have an audience of 50,000 people in the whole world. And historically, you couldn't build that business because it would have been impossible to find that 50,000 people out of billions. Now you can. [02:03:16] S4: Mhmm.